All articles

Local Law 84 Benchmarking: Who Must File & Rules

Every year by May 1, owners of covered NYC properties face a mandatory reporting deadline with the Department of Buildings (DOB). The requirement governing this process is the NYC Benchmarking Law, Local Law 84 of 2009 as amended by Local Law 133 of 2016. Meeting this requirement requires pulling utility consumption records, logging into an online federal database, and submitting an annual energy and water report directly to the City.

Missing the annual filing deadline carries a reporting penalty. Failing to display the required rating label carries a separate fine. Here is the operational breakdown of how to verify your building's status, handle data collection in the reporting software, track quarterly catch-up windows, and resolve penalties if your filing runs off track.

Checking If Your Property Must Comply

You do not need to guess whether your property is subject to reporting. The City identifies required properties annually through official records tied to your property identification numbers.

To find out if you are required to benchmark, review your property tax bills from the Department of Finance (DOF) for a section called One City Built to Last - Compliance Notification. You can also review the Covered Buildings List published annually for your borough, block and lot (BBL) number.

If you believe your property is erroneously listed on the Covered Buildings List due to the square footage of your building, contact DOF at sustainablebuildings@finance.nyc.gov. Keep the coverage question separate from the filing task. As a practical starting point, compare the property identification on your tax bill with the entry on the Covered Buildings List. Do not assume that a mailing address or a familiar building nickname establishes whether you are covered. The official guidance points owners to the tax-bill notification and the BBL entry, not a guess based on how large the building looks.

If a manager or outside representative handles reporting, ask them to retain the coverage record they relied on. That is an organizational suggestion, not a new eligibility test. Where the records appear inconsistent, use the official guidance rather than making your own exemption decision. This guide deliberately does not supply a floor-area threshold.

How ESPM Reporting Works

The law standardizes reporting for covered properties by utilizing the United States Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) online benchmarking tool, Energy Star Portfolio Manager® (ESPM). Building owners or designated representatives must enter and submit whole-building usage data to the City through this interface.

Here is how the reporting process operates from account setup through submission:

The following is a suggested working checklist, not an additional set of legal requirements. Use the current tool instructions and DOB guidance for the actual submission:

  • Confirm who handles the report. Decide which owner, manager or reporting representative will coordinate the work. Avoid a situation where everyone assumes another person submitted it.
  • Review access to the reporting tool. Locate the relevant Energy Star Portfolio Manager account and confirm that the person handling the filing can work with the correct property record. Treat access problems as preparation issues to resolve, not reasons to assume the deadline changes.
  • Organize the consumption records. Gather the energy and water usage information that will support the report. Keep records organized by property so data from different buildings is not casually mixed together.
  • Check the entries against your records. Before submitting, review the information entered in the tool against the material you gathered. Ask about gaps or discrepancies rather than filling them with unsupported guesses. Follow the current ESPM instructions for the details of data entry.
  • Complete submission to the City. The official requirement is to enter and submit usage data through the EPA tool by May 1st of every year. Merely collecting bills is not the same task as submitting the usage data.
  • Retain your working file. As a practical recordkeeping measure, save the material you used and any available submission record. Give the owner and reporting representative a shared understanding of what was completed and what remains unresolved.

A clean handoff is useful when management changes or someone else takes over the filing. Keep coverage records, reporting access and submission records together rather than leaving them scattered across individual inboxes. These are workflow suggestions; they do not replace the City's reporting instructions or establish new mandatory forms.

Filing Deadlines and Catch-Up Windows

May 1 is the annual reporting deadline. The quoted quarterly dates are catch-up opportunities after a missed report, not substitutes for the annual deadline. Do not treat a later filing window as a promise that penalties disappear.

Compliance WindowDeadline DateStatus / Enforcement Action
Primary Annual DeadlineMay 1Required submission deadline for annual benchmarking report
Quarterly catch-up (1st)August 1First quarterly catch-up deadline to submit overdue reporting
Quarterly catch-up (2nd)November 1Second quarterly catch-up deadline to submit overdue reporting
Quarterly catch-up (final)February 1 (following year)Final quarterly catch-up deadline for previous compliance year
Label display dutyWithin 30 days after October 1 of every yearPrint and display near each public entrance

If you do not submit a report by May 1, you may aim for the next quarterly deadline of August 1. Subsequent deadlines are November 1 and February 1 of the following year.

DOB Penalties for Missing Filings

The Department may issue a Notice of Violation to any property on the Covered Buildings List that has not provided a fully compliant benchmarking report by the May 1 deadline.

Failure to submit the report by May 1 will result in a penalty of $500.00. Continued failure to report usage by the next quarterly deadline may result in additional violations penalties of $500 per violation, up to $2000 per year.

Keep the reporting penalty separate from the label-display fine discussed below. The quoted annual reporting cap is not a statement about every possible building-compliance charge. If you receive a notice, read what it identifies rather than assuming every energy-related violation concerns a missing report. The official DOB page is the place to check current instructions for handling the notice.

Energy Star Grades and Building Display Rules

The official guidance describes building grades based on Energy Star energy efficiency scores, including categories for missing benchmarking information and exempt or non-covered buildings. As per Local Law 95 of 2019 grades based on Energy Star energy efficiency scores will be assigned as follows:

  • A: Score is equal to or greater than 85
  • B: Score is equal to or greater than 70 but less than 85
  • C: Score is equal to or greater than 55 but less than 70
  • D: Score is less than 55
  • F: Assigned to buildings that didn't submit required benchmarking information
  • N: Assigned to buildings exempted from benchmarking or not covered by the Energy Star program

Print and display the label in a conspicuous location near each public entrance within 30 days after October 1 of every year.

Failure to timely display the Building Energy Efficiency Rating label will result in a fine of $1,250.

Challenging Benchmarking Violations

If you believe a violation was issued in error, you may submit a Benchmarking Violation Challenge Form. This form must be sent to the Department within 30 days of the violation postmark.

As a practical first step, retain the notice and the envelope showing the postmark, then compare the allegation with your records. Use the current official form and instructions rather than treating an informal message or a phone conversation as a substitute for the required challenge form. This guide does not promise that a challenge will be accepted or that making a challenge cancels the underlying reporting obligation.

A coverage disagreement is a different question from a disputed violation. The quoted DOF contact applies when you believe your property is erroneously listed because of its square footage. The challenge form applies when you believe the violation was issued in error. Keep those tasks distinct in your working file and check the official page for the current process. Do not invent a new filing deadline while trying to resolve either issue.

For more detailed technical parameters, consult the official DOB benchmarking guidance.

Related NYC compliance deadlines

For a practical next step, Run the building lookup or call our compliance desk at (917) 408-3905.

For related building guidance, see our NYC local laws guide.

Want this handled for you?

Run a free scan of your building or call us and we’ll take it from there.